- Parent Category: Learning
- Created on Monday, 28 November 2011 04:57
- Published Date
The value of an MBA degree has been widely criticised by scholars and business practitioners. Criticism includes assertions that business schools are too ‘academic’ meaning somehow that they fail to provide what the business world needs, or that they fail to impart useful skills or to prepare leaders. Some assert that an MBA does not lead graduates to good corporate jobs.
However, personal experience in the domain of the MBA, from both a student and institutional perspective, has convinced me that the MBA adds unquestionable value to the individual as well as provides for organisational growth. To take it a level further, it is my view that the collective output of MBAs from business schools in a country benefits the nation. There are definite positive results from creating learning environments that promote growth-producing experiences for students.
In most cases, students are the principal players in the teaching-learning transaction. Having an understanding that modern management requires the practical implementation of skills learned has seen the emphasis in MBA education shifting more towards perception, creative thinking and learning. In other words, an MBA now involves the complete being and engages the student cognitively, emotionally and physically.
The impact of the three modes stimulated together shifts an MBA student’s perspective in a way that a focus on the cognitive part alone cannot. An MBA simulates an environment in which the student performs as close as possible to the manner in which it would happen in a business reality by immersing them in the milieu, requiring practice of the skills and receiving constructive feedback from an expert.
The MBA discourages the separation of thinking (formulation) from acting (implementation), because the world does not stand still while the formulation process takes place. MBA education recognises the complexity of the environment and that learning takes place through only a partly controlled, creative conscious thought process. In creating a learning environment, MBA educators provide for conversational learning, acting and reflecting, feeling and thinking, and influencing students to take charge of their own learning.
The challenges of the post-modern business landscape require leaders/managers to have a multidisciplinary skill-set. The multifaceted nature of the MBA and its orientation towards integrating all parts of the whole is therefore the ideal incubator for post-modern leaders.
At Milpark Business School the curriculum is designed to ensure a strong focus on the needs of the context and society, and on global events that influence the stability of local business. The MBA comprises two stages, the first of which provides a sound basis in core business management and leadership skills; the second focuses on integrated management, advanced leadership skills and global economics, including developing countries.
A significant shift in the student’s orientation takes place during the arduous MBA journey. The student’s perspective of the world of work and business widens with the achievement of each milestone or module completed. Ultimately, the new paradigm is practically applied when the journey culminates in the production of a dissertation, using appropriate academic register and business-aligned skills to demonstrate the ability to do independent research and to address real-life problems or opportunities within the context of the industry from which the student comes.
In the final analysis, feedback from MBA alumni and private and public industry stakeholders is overwhelmingly positive in terms of the value the MBA programme has added to the individuals and the organisations they serve. Recently published media surveys support this, and any doubts to the value of the MBA should diminish when reading the articles.
Not acknowledging and recognising the value of the MBA and the outstanding work that so many business schools have done and continue to do in empowering and equipping MBA’s will be short-sighted in my view.
Dr Cobus Oosthuizen is the Dean of the Faculty of Management and Leadership at Milpark Business School.
We have 26 guests and no members online